Holy shit.
I am nearly speechless after watching The Grove, which could easily be the best episode of Season 4 unless the final two episodes end up being super-awesome and incredible. I mean, wow. Just, wow. This could end up being the Season 4 equivalent of Clear.
After the past few installments of the season, I was starting to get tired of the bottle episodes, clamoring for Rick and Michonne to return. This is one of those moments where I realize that I should’ve just held my tongue. I wouldn’t trade in this episode for anything and I’m so glad this story had its own full hour in which to develop.
This episode had it all and it’s really what The Walking Dead is all about. It had amazing character development for both the adults and the children. The acting and writing was all incredible. The entire episode kept me in suspense, and even when the group found what seemed to be a good shelter, it always seemed very dark with a constant feeling of impending dread. I just knew that there was no way things were going to end well.
Carol, Tyreese, and even Lizzie and Mika were all fantastically developed in this episode. Their respective actor and actresses all did incredible, I thought, especially Melissa McBride who delivered one of the best television performances I have seen. You could practically feel Carol’s heart breaking and I felt myself hurting with her. Chad Coleman also delivered in such an incredible way that I’m now a much bigger Tyreese fan than I was before.
I also liked hearing the characters talk about the ones they’ve lost, such as Carol remembering Sophia and Tyreese talking about his nightmares about Karen. I like when the deaths of characters actually mean something, so it was nice to see Carol and Tyreese express their hurt over the ones that have died. It was like when Daryl talked about Merle in his bottle episode with Beth. Those other people may be gone but it’s nice to see that they’re not forgotten.
I have to admit that Lizzie killing Mika might not have been as surprising for us fans of the books who might have been expecting this to be the TV version of a similar event from the comics. However, I say that this is one of those rare times when the TV show managed to pull off a comic book scene much more efficiently— and don’t get me wrong, I loved the similar storyline from the comic. But, the characters involved on the show were developed so much better, and Carol’s discovery of the scene and subsequent actions were far more emotional and heartwrenching than what happened in the other medium.
I didn’t realize at first that Carol was taking Lizzie outside to execute her. I thought she was serious about her plans to just run off with Lizzie, keeping her away from all other people. But I think Carol realized that Lizzie was simply too far gone and was psychologically never coming back. Trying to keep Lizzie hidden from the world for the rest of their lives was simply not a good life to live, especially when you consider it was probably just a matter of time before Lizzie got herself devoured by the walkers she loved so much.
This way, Lizzie can go quickly without even realizing it, the final thing she sees being something pretty. Lizzie, in her sick mind, thought she was doing something good for her sister, so now she won’t have to deal with the realization that she murdered Mika and that Mika would never come back. She won’t get bitten and slowly die from the fever. She won’t be munched on to death. She got to look at the pretty flowers in the grove before moving on to the next life.
I will say that the scene reminded me of George and Lennie from Of Mice and Men. The obvious difference, though, is that Lennie wanted to tend the rabbits while Lizzie wanted to skin them.